Keiichi Anime Forever Forum - anime news, chat, discussion, and more for anime otakus



Forum Rules SOTW Winner:

SOTW Winner


by: Kurinshin Theme: Summer

  [Reply] [New Topic] [New Poll]

> IBF vs Metameta
IBF
Posted: 2009-08-04, 12:34 AM


Seraphim Lord

*

Group: General Section Moderators
Posts: 2,860
Joined: 5 September 2004

DarkOffline



Theme: Shakugan no Shana *vomits*
First to 6 wins

Good luck!


IBF: user posted image

Metameta: user posted image
[PM]
[QUOTE]
xFlcl
Posted: 2009-08-04, 12:37 AM


[HERO]

*

Group: Local Resident
Posts: 1,670
Joined: 10 July 2005

DarkOffline



IBF gmv.
I like it, except that the effects behind her a little too blurred... I dunno just seems off to me, and the thing on the right seems cut off, but oh well.

I like the colors in Meta's, but I don't like the effects over shana and the brightness in the signature. It's also a bit over pixeled and I believe that's because of either the effects or the brightness, might even be both.

Both nice sigs but ibf's gmv in this one.


-------------------

user posted image
|Fanlisting: Gurren Lagann|
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Raisurinu
Posted: 2009-08-04, 11:39 AM


Mugendai Touken

*

Group: Root Administrator
Posts: 4,100
Joined: 27 August 2004

DarkOnline



IBF GMV since the colors match/blend in better than Meta's. Meta's just looks really busy and has no focus on the character. In fact Shana looks like she's being obscured. >:


-------------------
user posted image
Thanks to IBF for the awesome sig~
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Sakon and Ukon
Posted: 2009-08-05, 08:45 PM


「 likes stuff 」

*

Group: General Section Moderators
Posts: 7,255
Joined: 14 February 2006

RisaOffline



IBF GMV, it's pretty, a lot of stuff like C4D's, used there though, and I don't really like the render. '-' She looks really weird, it might be her mouth....

EDIT FOR IBF: >: FEIN I FIXED IT....


-------------------
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Gill
Posted: 2009-08-06, 12:52 PM


Learning Otaku

*

Group: Local Resident
Posts: 33
Joined: 24 June 2009

DarkOffline



IBF GMV.
I like the colors, and the depth, but seems C4D whored(Am I allowed to say that?).

As for Meta, the colors seemed random and didn't go well together, also had too many effects with no flow. The focal is drowned out and you should have made the border smaller.
[PM]
[QUOTE]
jigglyness
Posted: 2009-08-08, 11:11 PM


make the difference♥

*

Group: Local Resident
Posts: 586
Joined: 8 July 2005

Offline



IBF gmv. I like the lighting in the middle but it feels like its missing something. The flow is a little clashing but it doesn't affect the rest of the sig too much.

metameta// I would've voted for this one if the effects weren't overlapping the render's face and if the colors weren't as saturated. The text area also catches my eyes more than the render.


-------------------

user posted image
TokyoSweets | Junior Boys - In The Morning | Sig - UKI <3
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Sennin
Posted: 2009-09-06, 06:09 PM


Who's Sennin?

*

Group: Local Resident
Posts: 5,973
Joined: 6 February 2005

DarkOffline



IBF gmv.
I like the left side, the middle isn't too bad but the brush work to the right needs to be fixed.
Good blending overall though, and nice use of colour; its at the point where any more would've made things TOO bright.


-------------------
user posted image
[PM]
[QUOTE]

[Reply] [New Topic] [New Poll]