SOTW Winner:
IBF vs Flcl
| Keiichi Anime Forever Forum Rules (Rev. 154) Chat | Help Search Usergroups Members Calendar |
| Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register ) | Account Services |
![[Closed Topic]](/style_images/2/t_closed.gif) ![[New Topic]](/style_images/2/t_new.gif) ![[New Poll]](/style_images/2/t_poll.gif) |
IBF vs Flcl| xFlcl |
Posted: 2009-08-03, 09:57 PM
|
 [HERO] 
Group: Local Resident
Posts: 1,670 Joined: 10 July 2005   |
Theme: Fate/Stay Night
First to 5 wins! Good luck~ IBF: 
Flcl:  -------------------
 |
![[PM]](/style_images/2/p_pm.gif)
![[QUOTE]](/style_images/2/p_quote.gif)
|
| Metameta |
Posted: 2009-08-03, 10:00 PM
|
 完全無欠 
Group: Local Resident
Posts: 481 Joined: 31 December 2006 |
Very hard choice. but I'm going to have to go with Flcl on this one. I think the lighting is really great, and the skull thing faded on the left is really cool~Also I cant deny a signature that made the text fit just right on the sig a victory.
IBF also really good. They would be tied for me if Flcl didn't have the text, but again making text fit is really hard,but I also really like the lighting on yours as well. -------------------
Thanks for the sig Kurinshin<3 |
|
|
| Sakon and Ukon |
Posted: 2009-08-03, 10:39 PM
|
 「 likes stuff 」 
Group: General Section Moderators
Posts: 7,255 Joined: 14 February 2006  |
Flcl GMV, although I like the red coloring in IBF's, the oversaturation of Saber's eyes kinda throws me off. I dislike the lens flare, needs blended a little better, but overall it blends very nicely. :3 |
|
|
| Yoshiyuki |
Posted: 2009-08-04, 01:53 AM
|
 ❀ 
Group: Local Resident
Posts: 5,105 Joined: 18 March 2005 |
IBF GMV, even though his has large empty spaces. FLCL's imho uses space well but is too brightt for me. Also what the FREAK is up with that pattern thing going on the left? -------------------
 Thanks to DW for the sig. |
|
|
| Raisurinu |
Posted: 2009-08-04, 11:43 AM
|
|
Mugendai Touken 
Group: Root Administrator
Posts: 4,099 Joined: 27 August 2004 |
FLCL GMV. The signature is pretty nice looking and the lighting feels natural. As for IBF's it was the eyes that killed it for me. If the effect on the eyes were toned down a bit the decision on this may have been different. -------------------
Thanks to IBF for the awesome sig~ |
|
|
| Drifter |
Posted: 2009-08-04, 02:21 PM
|
 A Hammer of Justice! 
Group: Roleplay Moderator
Posts: 3,286 Joined: 26 February 2005  |
Flcl GMV. The signature makes decent use of space and the lighting works. I kind of like the text idea as well. Just like Yoshi, the pattern used to the left of her head bugs me. IBF's sig just doesn't have a lot in it. There are too many dark areas, and the areas with any color in them are also too dark. I liked the eye "flames" though, pretty neat. -------------------
[Bang set by Noise + King (Click for clan sig)] |
|
|
| Kurinshin |
Posted: 2009-08-05, 05:26 AM
|
 ■quis custodiet ipsos custodes■
Group: General Section Moderators
Posts: 3,343 Joined: 4 September 2005 |
Again, like the rest, this is very close. But I gotta give my vote to xflcl. If it weren't for the text, which fits in so beautifully, my vote might have been different.
For IBF's sig, I think it was the eyes that threw me, and the bottom left corner is just too saturated. I really like both sigs though, good job both of you! -------------------
<3 Uki Like to make graphic art? Go participate in KAF's SOTW political correctness is tyranny with manners |
|
|
| |
© Copyright 2004 and beyond Keiichi Anime Forever. The opinions expressed herein are those of their authors and not necessarily those of Keiichi Anime Forever, its staff, and its affiliates. See our terms of service.
Powered by PHP, some Aurora, and Invision Power Board
1/7
