Theme: Favorite Cartoon Character
Voting Deadline: July 22nd

The sigs are arranged and numbered based on order of submission.
Please explain your votes from an artistic/graphical point of view.
Participants are allowed to vote but they may not vote for themselves.
Avoid repeating or quoting previous voting reasonings. You must provide your own explanation. Votes simply agreeing to another, will NOT be counted
Unexplained votes will not be counted.




1. by Dude Man

2. by Mistic-Gohan

3. by kyoui (2 votes)

4. WINNER! By jigglyness (6 votes)

5. by Sempai-Kun

6. by Kenpachi Zaraki (1 vote)

Thank you for voting. And thanks to those who submitted sigs.

This post has been edited by Inuyasha's BAMF Friend on 2008-07-22, 10:00 PM

#4 gmv

#1: Very little thought on placement, blending, or coloration.

#2: Nice idea, but the coloration, and text placement are a bit off.

#3: A bit oversaturated, and the text doesnt fit the piece very well, the corner placement doesnt help the piece much.

#4: A little over sharpened but has very good effects, and lighting, and coloration.

#5: I love some parts of this piece, but the bad C4D usage, and general sharpness, and blandness of this piece ruin the good parts.

#6: I like almost everything about this piece except its totally unblended and the text could be a bit better.

Good job to all competitors! ;D

#4 GMV

Crits

#1: The evil-looking face of the coyote made me chuckle, but it immediately appears like something you could make in paint. Good idea, just really low-quality.

#2: Once again, good idea, and the effects fit the theme of Samurai Jack. My complaint is that there's just way too much going on, and the text just sort of bothers me for some reason.

#3: It looks really nice, but I can't really tell what was done to this one. It looks just like someone took a picture from Thundercats and just pasted it into the borders of a sig. Who knows, maybe I should be looking at that as a good thing.

#4: Even though I voted for it, it still has problems. I picked it for the way the effects fit the Avatar style, and the simplicity of it just works. The text was also a good choice. My problem with it is that the image is little too sharp.

#5: ALL HAIL ZIM! It's a nice sig, but I noticed that the borders aren't proportional. Plus, the effects on the left make it look like his arm's exploding.

#6: This came in close second for me. The colors are pleasing to the eye, and the efffects work with the sig. The unreadable text on the left kind of bothers me though, and the "G" in PPG looks like it's melting or something.

4 gmv as well. Very good execution.

#4 for me too. I think Zuko is a little over sharpened, but everything else is nice.

#6 was my second favorite. Power Puff Girls FTW.

#6 GMV. it has a very pleasing sense to it and I like the text. besides, Power Puff Girls rocked! a lot better than all this new crap Cartoon Network is coming out with

I vote for #4.

1. Decent choice of images. Bad fonts. Background too empty and plain.
2. Overall not bad. Bad font. Not fond of color choice.
3. Looks good. Not a fan of the fire effect.
4. Has potential. Consider trying a different method of anti-aliasing to reduce the frailness of the type. Background is undersaturated and overly complex in certain regions.
5. Colors are good. Bad font styling. Too much empty space. Background doesn't fit foreground.
6. Interesting concept. Bad font & font styling. Background and its color are dull.

Numbah 3 gets my vote... I like the way its colored and put together... And plus... THUNDAH THUNDAH THUNDERCATS HOOOOOOOO!

Today and tomorrow are the last days to get your votes in for this week's SOTW.

lol hopefully I'm not today late at voting, but anyways.

My vote goes to #4, it's easy on the eyes, Zuko is abit sharpened, but it's still very good.

Absolutely #3.

I love the blending and the overall composition of this sig, I'm shocked it hasn't gotten more votes!

THUNDACATS~

With a total of 6 out of 9 counted votes, I'm pleased to declare jigglyness as the winner of SOTW 46. Congratulations!

I hope to see you all in our next SOTW.

Thanks to all contestants and to everyone who voted.
(Names of the contestants have been added next to their sigs.)