Keiichi Anime Forever Forum - anime news, chat, discussion, and more for anime otakus



Forum Rules SOTW Winner:

SOTW Winner


by: Kurinshin Theme: Summer

  [Closed Topic] [New Topic] [New Poll]

> SOTW 44 - Voting
Mudkip
Posted: 2008-06-14, 09:57 PM


\\forgotten.

*

Group: General Section Moderators
Posts: 2,933
Joined: 5 September 2004

DarkOffline



SOTW 44
Theme: Fighting Games
Voting Deadline: June 21st

The sigs are arranged and numbered based on order of submission.
Please explain your votes from an artistic/graphical point of view.
Participants are allowed to vote but they may not vote for themselves.
Avoid repeating or quoting previous voting reasonings. You must provide your own explanation. Votes simply agreeing to another, will NOT be counted
Unexplained votes will not be counted.




1. by xFlcl
user posted image


2. by kyoui
user posted image


3. by Amatsu
user posted image


4. Winner! By Kenpachi Zaraki (4 votes)
user posted image



Thank you for voting. And thanks to those who submitted sigs.
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Amatsu
Posted: 2008-06-15, 12:27 AM


~I'm Baaaaack~

*

Group: Local Resident
Posts: 3,174
Joined: 13 June 2005

DarkOffline



#4 GMV.

The text isn't as best as it could be, but the blending of the renders is amazing, I love the soft brushing along with the render placement.


-------------------
user posted image
[PM]
[QUOTE]
UkiUsaki Ikasu
Posted: 2008-06-15, 12:51 PM


Wi₪gℓeﻜﻜ A₪gel

*

Group: Local Resident
Posts: 7,143
Joined: 24 February 2005

DarkOffline



4 GMV
Even though I hate that maple leaf brush there... it's really a negative part of the sig. Out of all of them, it has the best coloration, very soft and easy to the eye... not too crowded, and it has the best-integrated typography out of all of them.

Primary problems for the rest are:
1. too monotonous. oversmudged edges.
2. too much goin on. good grasp of PS techniques but a sig that small.. should have less stuff in it.
3. oversaturation killed the sig.... (composition is nice though)
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Kurinshin
Posted: 2008-06-15, 02:55 PM


■quis custodiet ipsos custodes■

*

Group: General Section Moderators
Posts: 3,411
Joined: 4 September 2005

DarkOffline



#4 GMV

#1: Text/Placement is really needs work, the outer glow really takes away from it, making the focal awkward. The piece itself needs to have a clearer focal, I'd try sharpening your render in some spots to give a sense of depth.

#2: My second choice; however its coloring threw me off, the render is white and yellow, and the general color is redish orang, not a big problem, a gradient map would fix that quickley. The text also needs work.

#3: This one was just really oversaturated, the effects could use some variation as well.

#4: Pretty nice, unique comp. (though the left is really empty). Text could be better and the leaf looks really bad, mostly because it's smushed and blurry. I like the overall layout of the sig, and color work.


-------------------
user posted image
<3 Uki
Like to make graphic art? Go participate in KAF's SOTW
political correctness is tyranny with manners
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Sempai-Kun
Posted: 2008-06-16, 11:20 AM


I'm on my Go Go Gadget Flow!

*

Group: Local Resident
Posts: 172
Joined: 12 March 2008

DarkOffline



#4 GMV


It's well put together. It's very sharp and crisp I like the lighting effects done also, it's bright but not too bright.


-------------------
user posted image
Don't look at my boobs!
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Mudkip
Posted: 2008-06-21, 03:02 PM


\\forgotten.

*

Group: General Section Moderators
Posts: 2,933
Joined: 5 September 2004

DarkOffline



Voting for this weeks SOTW ends tonight at 11PM.
[PM]
[QUOTE]
Mudkip
Posted: 2008-06-21, 10:03 PM


\\forgotten.

*

Group: General Section Moderators
Posts: 2,933
Joined: 5 September 2004

DarkOffline



Oh wow. Due to a unanimous vote, I'm happy to announce that Kenpachi Zaraki (Nasaware-kun) is the winner of this week's SOTW. Congratulations!

Thanks to everyone who participated and to those who voted.

(The names of the participants will be added next to their sigs.)
[PM]
[QUOTE]

[Closed Topic] [New Topic] [New Poll]