Theme: Smudge or grunge

Size: Any

Rules: First to 5.



Anorudo

mc2w

Anorudo gmv.

Better composition, it's blended well, text is a little hard to read, but other then that, it's good.

The other one is too saturated for my taste, and it's almost as if Gaara has no body. All you can see is his face, hands and the sand jar. Plus, the bg doesn't really go with the stock.

mc2w's. Because it has better quality and because Gaara is awesome!

Your vote will not be counted unless you clearly explain why you like the sig.

mc2w because I love Gaara and that your pic is barely visible to me and your text to blended to read.
So I vote for mc2w.

1-1


Thanks for the criticism Ryuji. I know the typo sucks but, I was in a hurry.

Quoted^(ref) Kiku (on 1 April, 2007, 02:31 PM PDT) —

mc2w because it looks better.

Please explain why you like his sig best. Your just saying "Yeah cool", "Looks good", "Looks better". Explain why you like his better.

Dark Sennin has stated that, that is now considered spamming.

I pick mc2w because Gaara in the sig stands out more than Anorudo's. mc2w's sig text I can read and I really like patterns. It's really colorful and not colorless. So I vote for mc2w's too.

2-1.

Can we please get some real GFX artists to vote?

Anorudo GMV:

The flow is a lot better and the text, though I wasn't fond of it...It's still better compared to the other.

Mc2w's sig is like a picture darkened a bit and maybe with a filter or two on it and then some simple text and a brush, doesn't look good at all. I bet the psd file probly has about 6-7 layers.

So Anorudo GMV:

Mostly because the backround is epic level and that person's emotions seem expressed inside of the backround. The render seems to flow really good. The only downside is the text, way to hard to read.

3-2.